Discussion about this post

User's avatar
M. A. Istvan Jr.'s avatar

"Business Casual" is a satirical and darkly humorous poem that redefines the nature of evil, arguing that its most pervasive and chilling form is not overt horror or extreme violence, but rather the mundane, bureaucratic, and "corny" aspects of organized banality. It functions as a critique of institutionalized evil and the normalization of the absurd, challenging conventional notions of what constitutes true "shadow" or horror.

Formally, the poem is structured as an argument by negation and redefinition. It begins by explicitly dismissing traditional, sensationalized images of evil: "not Nazi ovens / or Pompeiian pyroclastic ash clouds, / let alone crucifix pussy stabs / or pea-soup horror tropes—". This immediate rejection of graphic and extreme forms of horror sets up the poem's central thesis. The enjambment between these lines creates a quick, dismissive rhythm, underscoring the speaker's contempt for these conventional representations. The core assertion then arrives: "that—not Nazi ovens...— / is the truer face of shadow:". The "that" refers back to the opening line, "All of it is corny as hell," establishing banality and "corniness" as the true essence of terror. The final lines provide the clinching evidence for this argument: "even satanist organizations / have lanyards, QR codes, PayPal / portals for quarterly dues." This juxtaposition of the inherently transgressive and frightening (satanist organizations) with the utterly mundane and bureaucratic (lanyards, QR codes, PayPal, quarterly dues) is the poem's comedic and critical punchline. It highlights the insidious creep of corporate and bureaucratic structures into every corner, even those traditionally associated with rebellion or profound evil.

Thematically, the poem delves into the banality of evil, echoing Hannah Arendt's famous concept, but twisting it to include not just the administrative aspects of horrific acts, but the inherent "corniness" and tediousness of even seemingly "dark" organizations. It suggests that the true "shadow" or threat is not the spectacular manifestation of malevolence, but the insidious process by which anything, even radical evil, can be subsumed by corporate structure, routine, and a veneer of "business casual" normalcy. The poem implies that the most terrifying aspect of evil is its capacity to be systematized, regularized, and stripped of its dramatic flair, thereby becoming less recognizable and more easily integrated into the fabric of everyday life. By humorously reducing satanism to a corporate entity, the poem critiques the pervasive influence of corporate culture and bureaucracy, suggesting that these forces are the ultimate homogenizers, draining even the most extreme forms of human expression or belief of their inherent danger or meaning, leaving behind only the "corny" husk of organizational ritual.

satire, banality of evil, institutionalization, bureaucracy, corporate culture, mundane, horror, evil, normalization, absurdity, dark humor, social commentary, critique, contemporary poetry.

Expand full comment

No posts